When is the best time to drink a protein shake? Here's what one supplement scientist thinks

Do you need to down a shaker full straight after your workout? Probably not

Woman's hand reaches for a chocolate protein shake in a see-through bottle. She is sitting cross-legged on the floor with couches behind her
(Image credit: Berk Ucak / Getty Images)

A protein shake is a quick and convenient way to increase your protein intake, but is there an optimal time to drink one? Some people have one immediately after a workout, others prefer one before bed. However, Steven Kahn, a product development scientist at Onnit, suggests there may be a tendency to overthink the issue.

When is the best time to drink a protein shake?

"I don't think there's a bad time to take whey protein," says Kahn. "Ultimately, as long as you're hitting your daily protein goals, that's more important than the timing of anything you’re eating or consuming."

However, Kahn says there could be a benefit in reaching for your shaker soon after your gym session.

"You are going to have a slightly better response to protein immediately post-workout, especially if you're training fasted in the morning. The impact would be a little more elevated because it would be the first food entering your system, whereas if you were to eat a couple of meals beforehand there would already be amino acids in your system. If that's the case, the protein you're getting from that protein shake wouldn't be as consequential."

Onnit Whey Protein
Subscribe and save

Onnit Whey Protein

Get $15 off 30 servings of Onnit's whey protein powder when you first subscribe (don't worry, you can cancel anytime). It's made using whey isolate, a more refined kind of whey that's lower in fats and carbs—the vanilla flavor is 110 calories per serving, with only 2g of fat and 3g of carbs, making space for 20g of protein!

How much protein should you have a day?

According to Kahn, the amount of protein you're consuming each day is more important than the timing. So, how much should you be getting?

"It depends," says Kahn. "If somebody gives me a straight answer, it's a red flag," says Kahn.

"In the US, the FDA has guidelines for the general population—it's 50g a day for protein—but that's for your ordinary person who is generally sedentary. They aren't going to the gym, they don't have fitness goals and they probably don't consume whey protein.

"The amount of protein you need depends on your goals. I was a powerlifter for a while so my goals focused on building strength and muscle. I've always stuck to consuming 1g of protein per 1lb of bodyweight. If you have a coach or nutritionist, get their input before you start tweaking those numbers."

Harry Bullmore
Fitness Writer

Harry Bullmore is a Fitness Writer for Fit&Well and its sister site Coach, covering accessible home workouts, strength training session, and yoga routines. He joined the team from Hearst, where he reviewed products for Men's Health, Women's Health, and Runner's World. He is passionate about the physical and mental benefits of exercise, and splits his time between weightlifting, CrossFit, and gymnastics, which he does to build strength, boost his wellbeing, and have fun.

Harry is a NCTJ-qualified journalist, and has written for Vice, Learning Disability Today, and The Argus, where he was a crime, politics, and sports reporter for several UK regional and national newspapers.